Skip to content
Independent reporting

Pressed on “illegal” Trump orders, Dems cite talk—not commands

Share X Facebook Email

The moment: At a Thursday press conference marking one year since a video urging service members to disobey “illegal” orders from then–President Donald Trump, Democratic lawmakers were pressed by The Gateway Pundit (TGP) to identify a single illegal Trump order. According to TGP’s account and video, none named a specific command.

Who was on stage, per TGP

TGP identifies the lawmakers tied to last year’s video as Sen. Mark Kelly (AZ), Elissa Slotkin (MI), Rep. Jason Crow (CO), Maggie Goodlander (NH), Chris Deluzio (PA), and Chrissy Houlahan (PA). TGP refers to the group as the “Seditious Six.”

The Gateway Pundit

What TGP asked—and what followed

TGP reporter Jordan Conradson says he asked whether Republicans should have urged troops to defy what TGP called “illegal” orders under Presidents Biden or Obama. TGP cites the COVID-19 vaccine mandate for troops under Biden as “legally questionable,” and a 2014 Government Accountability Office finding that the Obama administration violated notification law in the Bowe Bergdahl prisoner exchange.

According to TGP, Slotkin did not answer directly and turned to Rep. Jason Crow, who spoke broadly about following the law “regardless of your political background or affiliation,” without addressing the specific question.

The specific-order challenge

Conradson then asked the group to name one illegal order from Trump. TGP reports that Sen. Mark Kelly referenced Trump’s 2016 debate comments and a claim in former Defense Secretary Mark Esper’s 2022 memoir that Trump “entertained the idea” of having violent rioters shot in the legs. When asked whether any such direction became an order, TGP says Kelly responded that Trump discussed it with senior staff but did not cite an issued command.

TGP adds that the lawmakers moved on without naming a specific illegal order after further prodding.

About the year-ago video, per TGP

TGP says the lawmakers’ video told active-duty service members and intelligence officials they had a “duty” to disobey “illegal” orders from Trump as he increased pressure and strikes against designated foreign terrorist drug traffickers and Venezuela’s Nicolás Maduro. TGP characterizes the video as an attempt to “sow doubt and interfere with military operations.”

Source and attribution

All descriptions above are drawn from Jordan Conradson’s report for The Gateway Pundit and the outlet’s video of the exchange. This article has not independently verified the participants’ remarks, the setting, or the full context of related claims.

Share X Facebook Email

The Fear and Blood Brief

The day’s essential headlines, without the noise.

A concise briefing delivered directly to your inbox.

Free to join. Unsubscribe any time.

Powered by Reach Response